A guest article by Roger Fearn, a tour guide at Didcot Railway Centre.
I readily acknowledge that a great deal of this information has appeared in print before. I have amassed a great deal of information over the years, and much of it has been derived from those sources. There is no malicious intent to plagiarise anything that has gone before.
The story of the Great Western “King” class has been told many times over. The pre war exploits of these engines and their vital contribution during the Second World War, especially moving vast numbers of matelots, to and from Plymouth was extraordinary. I’m of an age, whereby, I only saw the Kings during their final swan song years and this no doubt influences my own focus on that particular part of their service life. The story of their later years and final demise is a fascinating one of “what ifs”. So peer with me into the past and join me on my take on that tale, from information which I have gathered, over more years than I care to remember. So here goes……
Let’s go back to May 1939…. It was at this time that, it had been noted by Swindon, that a French 4-6-0 locomotive, fitted with a Kylchap double blast pipe and chimney had demonstrated a clear and hugely significant performance advantage over that of a King. Here’s the important bit; although the available horsepower of the French locomotive was 25% less than the King at 80 mph, the power available at the cylinders was double that of the GWR engine. The outbreak of the Second World War undoubtedly prevented anything being done about it, but it was a matter which was plainly in the minds of everyone in the Chief Mechanical Engineer’s staff.
Post war, the Kings were not, along with countless other locomotives around the entire country, in the best of condition. The lack of maintenance, along with the excessive mileage accumulated, rendered them in need of urgent attention. By 1950, the average annual mileage for the Kings, was a disappointing 52,978, which contrasted sharply with 65,236 being achieved pre war, in 1937. In 1952, this fell further to 49,248, with an availability of the class in traffic barely scraping 56%. This clearly had the huge potential, to adversely impact the service being offered to the public.
A team, led by Sam Ell, was assembled at Swindon to establish a strategy to enable the class to cope better with post war conditions and some experiments were quickly put into place. The deteriorating quality of coal and labour shortages were among the challenges being faced. By 1952, all had been fitted with 4 row superheaters, mechanical lubricators and smokebox mesh plates, to assist with ash disposal as an initial response.
Following some detailed experiments with draughting, in the spring of 1953, 6001 King Edward VII, ran a number of loaded test runs between Reading (Scours Lane) and Stoke Gifford. These trains consisted of no less than 25 coaches, weighing a total of 800 tons. The tests demonstrated that the steaming rate improved by a huge 30%, above the standard design, with coal consumption at a very respectable 30 lbs per mile - a reduction of 8%. These modifications were quickly extended to the other 29 locomotives in the class.
While this solved an immediate problem, matters took a dramatic turn in January 1956, when cracks were discovered in the bogie frames of a number of Kings. As a precaution, the entire class was temporarily withdrawn for a detailed inspection. The defects discovered were significant enough to require additional strengthening braces to be added to the frames, rather than welding over the flaws, which would have been a more usual solution to such a situation and this took time. To cover the service shortfall that this caused, locomotives were borrowed from other regions and these included “Duchess” and “Princess Royal” Pacifics from the LMR, supplemented by a number of V2’s from the Eastern Region.
At this time, with the Kings clearly beginning to show their age, and the decision to either scrap them and seek replacement 8P power from other regions, or to make a major investment in renovating them became a more pressing matter and had to be made. As none of the other Regions were in a position to surrender any locomotives in this power class, the latter option was the only viable choice.
6015 King Richard III, had been fitted with a double chimney, at some significant expense, in September 1955 and tests had shown that in this condition, it was more than a match for the larger pacifics, used by other Regions and this was the basis for the planned refurbishment. With this new addition, 6015 had been tested on the Cornish Riviera Express in late September 1955 and achieved a speed just in excess of 100mph, twice on this service, the first occasion on the 26th of that month. On the 29th, it went one better and reached 108½ mph at Lavington on the train that day and remains the highest authentic speed recorded by a member of the class. It arrived at Plymouth within the 4 hour schedule, despite encountering delays exceeding 20 minutes during the course of the journey - an altogether astonishing performance.
Application of this arrangement to the rest of the class started with no 6012 in December 1955 and progressed until the final one to be fitted was to 6018 in March 1958. Such was the improvement, that this modification was fitted to “Castle” no 7018 in July 1956 and indeed a further 65 members of that class received this treatment, until increasing dieselisation abruptly halted the conversion programme in 1961.
Now here’s the fascinating piece; further major improvements were proposed at this time, but unfortunately prevailing conditions - most notably the beginning of the diesel revolution - conspired to prevent the work from taking place.
The first of these proposals was to consider arrangements which would improve the distribution of steam to the cylinders - the matter which had been identified in 1939. This would involve the reconstruction of the steam passages and the provision of new steel cylinders. As there was no steel foundry at Swindon, this would demand that the work be carried out by an outside source. At this time, the world’s best inside cylinder steel motion cradles for 4 cylinder engines, were manufactured by Krupp, in West Germany. It is probably due to the sensitivity of involving a German company, so soon after the war, that it was seen as politically impossible to use them.
In conjunction with this work, it was proposed to fit the class with roller bearings. This would have not only required new wheels, but also new frames to accommodate these features. A new boiler would additionally be required (in the event these were fitted anyway) and the only parts of the original engine remaining, would have been the motion, brake gear, running plates and cab. In effect, they would have been a virtual “new build” and the cost of the work was calculated at £12,500 (£405,000 at 2026 values) per locomotive.
Although the work, apart from the new boilers, was never done, no less than 8 sets of roller bearings had been purchased and delivered for the purpose, but were never used. These gathered dust at Swindon, until they were finally disposed of in about 1975. At this time, it was envisaged that steam would last into the late 1970’s (if only!) and this work would give them at least another 15 years of front line service life. The deteriorating financial position of BR, accelerated by industrial action, caused a rapid change in this policy and steam was to be replaced much more quickly than originally envisaged, so the project was abandoned. We can only imagine the performances, which might have emerged…..
The Kings were transformed with the work which was actually carried out, but their new lease of life was to be very short lived and here are some stark statistics; by 1962, the 16,000 steam locomotives working across the British Railways network only four years before, had been reduced by 25%. Whilst in this year of 1962, 84% of freight workings across the country were still powered by steam, the figure for main line passenger work was only 31%. This illustrates graphically, how when diesels arrived, they took the best work first, leaving the Kings, in this instance, with nothing suitable to do.
The end of the Kings really started as early as 1958, with the introduction of “Warship” class diesels on the West of England main line. On Saturday, 27th February 1960, the last of Plymouth Laira’s Kings, No. 6002 King William IV, was transferred away to Old Oak Common, which ended the allocation of class members to the shed, which had started way back in 1928 and had been a constant feature ever since.
During the summer of 1960, Kings were a rather rare sight on the West of England main line and eight of the class were transferred to Cardiff Canton for working London and Shrewsbury line expresses. Canton shed lost its allocation of “Britannia” class pacifics to the London Midland Region - who were clamouring for these locomotives - as a part of this process. Curiously, the Canton crews were not entirely happy with this arrangement. They had taken well to the Britannia’s - unlike most other Western sheds - and saw the deal, as one which was very much second rate. This was the first time the class had been based at this shed and probably ensured that withdrawal of the Kings did not commence a year earlier. At this stage, 11 of the class were based at Old Oak Common, a further 11 at Wolverhampton Stafford Road and the remaining 8 at Cardiff Canton. Dieselisation was, however, on the march and the Kings could not escape, especially with the new “Western” class locomotives, rapidly coming on stream.
The first to be withdrawn, was 6006 from Old Oak Common on 15th February 1962. 6003, 6004, 6010, 6023 and 6024 from Cardiff, together with 6008 and 6013 from Old Oak following in June. July marked the end for the first two Stafford Road engines (6017 and 6020), with 6029 from Old Oak joining them. September saw a major offensive on the survivors, with 6001, 6002, 6007 (the lowest mileage replacement following the 1936 Shrivenham crash), 6009, 6012, 6014, 6015, 6016, 6019, 6021, 6022, 6026 and 6027 being withdrawn - no less than thirteen engines in all. Of the six survivors, 6005 and 6028 were withdrawn in November from Old Oak, and of the remaining four examples, 6000, was officially withdrawn on 4th December and 6011, 6018 and 6025 taken out of service on 18th December.
That should have been the end of their operational story but during the last week of April 1963, 6018 King Henry VI, was steamed at Tyseley and worked a number of service trains between Birmingham Snow Hill and Leamington. This was in preparation for the Stephenson Locomotive Society, “Farewell to the Kings” rail tour, which ran from Birmingham to Swindon Works on 28th April, with 6018 doing the work. A top speed of 91mph was achieved during a sprint through Denham on this run and this really was the end.
It was discovered, around this time, that 6000 King George V, which had been earmarked for official preservation, had badly cracked frames. Serious consideration was given towards scrapping 6000 and have 6018 masquerade as KGV. Whilst in the event, this did not happen, 6018 had a further brush with survival, when Billy Butlin, the holiday camp magnate, was seeking engines to use as static attractions for his holiday camps. The purchase price quote apparently proved to be a little too high for Sir Billy and he opted instead for a cheaper LMS Stanier “Coronation” pacific. This was a great shame, as some work had been done in Swindon works, during the summer of 1963, in preparation for a holiday camp retirement, which in the event never came and instead it was scrapped at the works, at the beginning of October, 1963.
It had always been traditional for retired locomotives, to be dismantled at the main locomotive works of each railway company, usually in an area especially set aside for the purpose. Such were the rate of withdrawals in the late 1950’s and early 1960’s, however, that the works were simply overwhelmed by the volume of disposals. To address this, a process was set in place, to encourage private scrap metal contractors to place a bid for withdrawn locomotives and set about dismantling them, for their own profit. Thank goodness, one Dai Woodham was so successful in this respect.
There appears to have been a reluctance by both management and staff at Swindon to break up the Kings and indeed 6011 and 6025 were not dealt with until the first half of 1964. Astonishingly, 6010 clung on at Swindon until September 1965. In the event, 10 Kings were scrapped at Swindon, Cox and Danks in Oldbury managed to dismantle 11, whilst Cashmore’s consumed 4 at their Newport site and a further one at their Great Bridge premises, whilst the final one (no. 6028), succumbed to Bird’s at Risca.
All ran very significant mileages during their service life. The lowest - apart from 6007, which was a replacement locomotive, following the 1936 Shrivenham collision - was 6023, with 1,554,201 miles “on the clock” and the highest was 6013, accumulating 1,950,462. The reporting of individual locomotive mileage ceased on 28th December, 1963, when it was clear that there was no point in accumulating this information for traction which was soon to perish.
6023 and 6024 from Cardiff Canton had a remarkable escape from the cutter’s torch. Having been withdrawn in June, by late September 1962, they stood at Swindon awaiting their fate. One Sunday morning, during November, they were coupled up to a diesel and were towed westwards, towards their new owners, T.W. Ward’s of Briton Ferry, who had successfully won the “scrap bid” and had purchased them on 10th October, 1962.
Fate now stepped in; they had, during this journey, been spontaneously but conveniently used to participate in some dead weight testing on a bridge renewal near Bristol. It is difficult to avoid the distinct possibility that this brief activity may well have brought their intended, ultimate destination to the attention of the Civil Engineer, who promptly refused to allow them to travel onwards to Ward’s yards. The King class, carried a “Double Red” route restriction, given their high axle loading of 22 tons 10cwt. This precluded them for running over the route west of Cardiff which they would need to take, in order to reach the premises of their new “owners”. They had reached Severn Tunnel Junction by this time and here their journey abruptly ended, until the matter had been sorted out.
As a result of this difficulty, the sale to Ward’s was cancelled and they were resold onwards to Woodham Bros at Barry, on 26th November 1962. The Civil Engineer, acknowledged that Woodham’s yard at Barry was still west of Cardiff, but seemingly he was unconcerned about the structural integrity of this particular route, which goes down to Llantwit Major. It is here where they both remained until they were eventually rescued for preservation. What is for certain is that had they been delivered to Ward’s, it is extremely unlikely that they would have survived until New Year’s Eve, 1962 as this organisation, having acquired redundant locomotives, rapidly broke their purchases up on arrival. There is little doubt, that had these locomotives not been commandeered to perform the bridge weight testing during their journey towards Wales, it is highly unlikely that anybody higher up the chain of command would have been any the wiser about their planned destination and they would have continued with their journey unnoticed and then rapidly “consumed” by Ward’s.
The story of these two Kings at Barry and their subsequent existence, is yet another chapter in the almost miraculous tale, but how fortunate we are to have 6023, still in one piece, gracing the site at Didcot.