Locomotive identification from this period is not an exact science. The rapid decline and scrapping of steam in the 1960s was, by most accounts, something of a wild west: identification plates were stolen and sold on the black market, and in Britain's weather they were just as often replaced with numbers chalked onto the frames by hand — numbers that rarely survived the next spell of rain. A significant amount of data from that era is simply lost to time. What matters now is that everyone holding a genuine piece of the record has a duty to add it to that shared heritage, rather than fight over what scraps remain.
I said recently that I had no wish to revisit old disputes, and I meant it — this isn't about refighting them. But there's a difference between letting old arguments go and letting a false account of a dead man's honesty stand unanswered simply because it's easier not to look at it again. The facts below do the talking; I'm just the one putting them in one place.
Since 2009, the "What Really Happened to Steam" (WRHTS) project — the HSBT team of Terry Hayward, Richard Strange, Roger Butcher and Peter Trushell, working under the banner of the Engine Shed Society — has built a public case that my father's What Happened to Steam (WHTS) booklets, published between 1980 and 1985, contained serious errors. I'm not here to dispute that the books have mistakes in them. My father said so himself, in print, while he was alive to say it. What I want to put on record is how that acknowledgment has been treated since he no longer could — and what his own work, and his own words, actually show.
What my father actually said
When HSBT launched in The Railway Magazine in November 2009, my father wrote his own statement for that issue. He welcomed the project, explained that his information had come from the two sources available to him at the time — the enthusiast press and correspondence from fellow railwaymen, all offered to him in good faith — and gave the new research his backing.
It's worth being honest about the difference in circumstances. My father joined the fire brigade in the 1970s and was a full-time fireman for twenty years, raising a family with two children — and, like most firemen of that era, he held a second job around his shifts. He started Defiant Publications, running it out of a VW T2 camper van parked on the forecourt of the fire station between call-outs. I still remember our home kitchen converting into a photo printing studio some nights, my father working through until morning developing his photographs around his shift duties. He compiled his original records in whatever hours that left him — largely alone, with no team, no shared database, and no coordinated access to society archives, working from correspondence and the journals available to one person at the time. He was, in that sense, something of a Robinson Crusoe figure: resourceful with what washed up in front of him, doing it in his spare time on top of a full-time career, without anyone else's shoulder to check his work against. HSBT, by contrast, launched in 2009 as a named team of four, grew to around ten specialists with individually assigned regions and archive contacts, and has now had seventeen years, institutional backing from the Engine Shed Society, and coordinated access to the National Archives, works cut-books, and private breaker records that no single person compiling a reference work by hand in his spare time in the 1970s could have obtained. That a well-resourced team, working for over a decade, found things one man missed working alone isn't the indictment it's been presented as — it's what should be expected.
By 2013 my father had reviewed his own data and accepted that around 500 entries were wrong, acknowledging that he should have made clearer that the dates in his books were approximations rather than exact records. That is a man owning his mistakes publicly, while still alive to explain his methods and be judged on how he responded.
He didn't stop there. In July 2016, in a piece on this site called "A Phoenix Stirs," he published the results of re-researching the entire WHTS series himself, class by class: of 17,574 listed locomotives, he had by then confirmed 431 wrong entries — 2.5% of the total — a figure he described in his own words as far removed from the 2,500 HSBT had originally put about. That's a fivefold gap between HSBT's headline number and what he found when he went back through his own work and published the result under his own name, for anyone to check.
Correspondence he left behind
Among my father's papers is a personal correspondence with several members of the HSBT team, going back to the project's earliest days. It reads, at the start, exactly as his 2009 public statement suggests: warm, genuinely collaborative, an experienced compiler pleased to see gaps in his own work being filled by people with more time, more archive access, and more of a team around them than he ever had working alone. He shared data freely, and said so openly, in his own words, more than once.
What stands out, going back through it now, is how that early goodwill kept getting used. Lines from those first exchanges, and from his 2009 public endorsement, were repeatedly reused by the group in their own promotional material in the years that followed — presented as if they were a current, standing endorsement of the project, long after the correspondence itself had cooled considerably on both sides. Words given freely in 2009, in a genuine spirit of welcome, don't stop being quotable later just because the relationship behind them has changed — but it becomes something else to keep presenting them as unchanged when they weren't.
A year after HSBT launched, when it went public with its account of an anonymous correspondent it nicknamed "Zulu," said to have supplied around 2,500 fabricated disposal records, the project described my father in its own published words as the real injured party in that story, someone whose trust had been betrayed.
The kind of criticism he was already living with
My father gave his chief critic in these years a name of his own for what he described as a pattern of personal belittling carried out through the pages of the Engine Shed Society's own Link magazine. The man behind it was Roger Butcher: in Link issue 109 (Summer 2014), Butcher wrote that anyone who still believed his books had support "would need to live in a fantasy world of care bears and unicorns" to think so. Whatever the merits of the underlying research dispute, that isn't the language of measured correction — and it's worth knowing this was already the tenor of things while he was alive to answer back, not something that only appeared after he died.
He also had real, credible support outside the dispute. David Williams — editor of the Severn Valley Railway's own members' magazine, SVR News, for fifty-seven years until 2023 — gave him space in its pages to make his case, and is listed, by name, as one of the most-cited contributors in my father's own locomotive database. That's not a fringe endorsement; it's one of the longest-serving editors in the hobby, and someone whose name appears in the primary-source record itself, not just in a testimonial.
What changed after he died
My father passed away in October 2017, after a short battle with cancer. Three months later, Richard Strange published a piece — first in an outside bulletin, then reprinted in the Engine Shed Society's own magazine as Link issue 124 — that opened by acknowledging the convention against criticising someone who has just died, and then set that convention aside. The same 2,500-record figure HSBT itself had used in 2010 to explain most of the books' errors was recalculated down to roughly 15% of the total, with the remainder now attributed to my father's own compilation and his earlier account of events dismissed as insincere. The piece concluded that nothing in his books could be regarded as reliable at all — a conclusion that sits uneasily next to the 2.5% figure my father had already published, and defended, three years before he died.
I'd ask readers to notice the timing. Every earlier claim against my father's work was made while he was alive, in the same publications, with room for his own reply printed or posted alongside it. This one wasn't. It is by a wide margin the harshest assessment of his work published anywhere in this dispute, and it appeared at the one point he had no opportunity to answer it.
A detail the piece doesn't examine
There's a further point worth recording. That same article states that my father's principal source for disposal data — material from the RCTS's own Railway Observer — reached him via Peter Trushell. Trushell was one of HSBT's four founding members; the T in the project's own name. If that account is accurate, the data chain being cited as evidence of my father's unreliability runs directly through one of his critics' own founders. The article notes this in passing and moves on. I think it deserves more scrutiny than that.
How the website actually came to be
The real story is better than anything I could reconstruct secondhand, so I'll tell it as he did. He'd never touched a laptop before 2013. That summer, a colleague of mine got in touch, unhappy at how one-sided the public coverage of the dispute had become, and the two of us put a proposal to my father: take the original WHTS body of work, combine it with every correction he'd since confirmed, and put it online. He learned Twitter, Dropbox, YouTube, Facebook and Flickr from a standing start to make it happen. whathappenedtosteam.com launched on 13 December 2013, with every disposal now carrying its source — something he said himself, in hindsight, should have been in the original booklets all along.
Since his death, I've inherited and gone through the database that grew out of that launch. It tells a fuller story than either side's public statements do on their own.
The numbers, since numbers are Richard's preferred language
Richard has built his case almost entirely around percentages — 50% of the Cashmore entries wrong, 14.6% attributable to the fabricator, 85% of the Railway Observer's data supplied by one man. My father answered in exactly that currency himself, while he was alive: 431 confirmed wrong out of 17,574, or 2.5%. It's worth setting his own published figure alongside what his working database shows in full — 18,822 locomotives, 131,857 individually sourced entries, each one carrying his own reliability classification.
| Category (his own system)CountShare |
| Locomotive observed at location/date | 47,174 | 35.8% |
| Correct information | 45,390 | 34.4% |
| Note or explanation | 30,499 | 23.1% |
| Amendment to original entry | 3,487 | 2.6% |
| Marked incorrect information | 2,745 | 2.1% |
| Photograph | 1,899 | 1.4% |
| Query — conflicting sources | 663 | 0.5% |
- The "rogue correspondent" material shows up in his own records, independently of anything WRHTS has published. Around 1,610 entries across 1,589 locomotives carry his own flag for that source. He didn't discard them wholesale — each was individually reassessed: roughly 59% remained marked correct, with the rest split between marked-incorrect, queried, or amended.
- Of the entries he himself flagged as outright incorrect, the largest traceable cause — 57.6% — was the Railway Observer being wrong, not the fabricator. Only 19.8% of his self-flagged errors trace to the "rogue correspondent" marker at all.
- His sourcing spans over 200 distinct references, not two secondhand press outlets: alongside the Railway Observer (31.5% of all sourced entries), The National Archives at Kew accounts for 12.3% — the same archive series HSBT cites as their own primary-source advantage — plus several thousand entries drawn from his own firsthand observations.
- The database was not static. Update logs show tens of thousands of corrections entered in each of 2014, 2015, and 2016, and 17,159 more in 2017 alone — including entries dated as late as 12 and 17 September and 2 October 2017. He was correcting this record in the weeks before he died, at the same time the sharper public criticism of his work was being written elsewhere.
Even the RCTS's own editor, John Walford, argued in 2013 that "a block statement of this kind should always arouse scepticism in the mind of the historian" — said in response to one of HSBT's own claims at the time. It's a fair standard, and one HSBT's own side should be willing to have turned back on itself. A conclusion that nothing in these books is reliable deserves exactly that scepticism, when the man himself had already published a defensible, sourced 2.5% figure three years earlier, and his underlying working record shows a functioning, self-correcting error-tracking system running for years, including the years that criticism was being written.
Where this leaves things
None of this means my father's books were error-free. They weren't, and he said so — repeatedly, specifically, and with figures attached. But there is a difference between correcting a historical record and rewriting the terms of someone's culpability once they are no longer here to answer for it — and it's harder still to justify when his own published work and his own working records both show an active, self-critical correction process running for years. HSBT has said since 2010 that regional disposal books were forthcoming; none have appeared as of 2026, while sharper characterisations of my father's honesty have continued to be published in the meantime.
WHTS exists to do the constructive version of what both sides say they want: a properly sourced, continually correctable archive built from primary evidence and open contribution, rather than a fixed set of booklets frozen in the 1980s, or a set of magazine articles nobody can cross-examine. My father was already building that — quietly, then publicly, for years, on top of a full career and a family. If HSBT's research is as solid as claimed, I would welcome it being brought into that open record — rather than aimed, after the fact, at a man who can no longer reply.
— Stephen Hands, producer, WHTS